Statement of faith. A real conversation. That's the bar to get on this page. Not a rating of how fast they return calls, not a judgment on whether their deductibles are competitive, not a mystery-shop of how they handle a claim. We talk to every agent before they go live, confirm they're a real business, and require them to affirm Jesus as Lord and Savior. That's where our role ends.
So here's how to use this list well. The agents here are believers who chose to identify themselves publicly as Christian-owned. The reviews below are where you find out whether their clients would hand them a referral. A home-and-rental insurance agent who explains coverage gaps plainly, doesn't upsell you into policies you don't need, and actually picks up the phone when something goes wrong (honestly, that last one is rarer than it should be) is worth finding. Whether any specific agent here is that person is what the reviews are for.
On supply: there's genuine selection on this page. Enough that you can compare, read reviews side by side, and make a real choice rather than defaulting to whoever answers first. We won't pretend the list is exhaustive. It grows as more believing business owners join. But you're not starting from nothing, and that matters. Start with the reviews, ask about their claims process up front, and let the conversation do the rest.
States with listings
Listings (11)
Schwab Insurance
Goosehead Insurance - Steve Daniels Agency
Trevin Webb Insurance Agency Inc
Bob Keith Insurance Agency-Farmers
Blake Thomas - State Farm Agent
Alexander St. Cyr Insurance Agency
Simple Blessings Insurance Agency
Anchor Partners Group
Halkos Insurance Agency
Rest Assured Insurance & Financial Services,LLC
Hollis Insurance Agency LLC - Ohio
Frequently asked questions
How do agents get listed on this page?
Every agent signs our statement of faith affirming Jesus as Lord and Savior, and we have a real conversation with them before they go live. We confirm they're a legitimate business. That's the bar to be here.
Does LocateFaith vet the quality of an agent's work?
No. We confirm faith and identity, not performance. The reviews on each listing are where you learn whether past clients would recommend them. That's the right place to look.
What should I ask a home-and-rental insurance agent before hiring?
Ask how they handle claims, what common coverage gaps they see in policies like yours, and how reachable they are when something goes wrong. How they answer tells you a lot.
Is the list complete for my area?
It reflects the Christian-owned agents who have joined LocateFaith. The directory grows as more business owners sign up, so it's worth checking back if options feel thin right now.
Are rental and home insurance agents listed together?
Yes. Agents who cover both home and rental policies are listed on this page. Check individual profiles to confirm which products each agent offers in your area.